Why a Toxic Work Environment Is Especially Hard on High Achievers

It often takes high achievers longer than anyone else on their team to recognize a toxic work environment, even though they usually see the signs. The qualities that make you a high achiever, such as remaining calm under pressure, consistently delivering results, and being the person others depend on, are often the very qualities a toxic workplace takes advantage of. In a healthy workplace, these strengths are noticed and rewarded. In an unhealthy workplace, they're used to keep you producing long after the environment has stopped deserving it. Instead of questioning the workplace, you end up questioning yourself, convinced that if you just worked a little harder, the problem would improve.

Maybe you work in a corporate role and you're the one reworking the slide deck at eleven o'clock at night before the leadership meeting, then absorbing the fallout the next morning when a project you inherited falls behind schedule. Or maybe you're in academia, carrying a heavier advising load than anyone else in your department and serving on the committees nobody else wants, while the expectations for promotion seem to drift a little farther out of reach each year.

Either way, you've probably been told more than once that you're "so good under pressure." It's meant as a compliment, and for a long time, it has probably felt like one. But when the pressure never lets up, and you've started bracing yourself for work before the day even begins, that reputation starts to become less of a compliment and more of an expectation. Before long, the thing everyone admires about you becomes the very thing that's keeping you stuck.

What makes this especially tricky is that from the outside, everything looks fine. You’re still delivering, still dependable, still the one people go to. Because you keep performing, nobody around you notices that anything is wrong, and very often, neither do you. If you’ve already read through the signs of a toxic work environment and found yourself nodding along while also thinking but I’m handling it, this one is for you.

Because you keep performing, nobody around you notices that anything is wrong. Very often, neither do you.

When Being Good at Your Job Makes You a Target

Many high achievers carry a belief they’ve never said out loud: if I do excellent work, people will treat me fairly. In a healthy workplace, that is usually true. In a toxic one, research suggests it can work the other way around.

A study published in the Journal of Applied Psychology looked at nearly 5,000 university staff members and found that high performers were more likely to be on the receiving end of harmful behavior from their own colleagues. The researchers also examined whether the high performers' own behavior (for example, coming across as condescending) could account for that treatment. It did not. Instead, they found that envy was the strongest predictor of colleagues' harmful behavior. The same thing can also happen with managers. Research has found that supervisors who feel threatened by a high-performing employee are also more likely to treat that employee poorly.

If you’ve noticed that the better you do, the more distant certain people become, you may be seeing these findings in action. You may have tried to explain it away by telling yourself you’re imagining it or that you’re doing something that gives people the wrong impression. High achievers tend to look inward first, so the natural move is to tone it down: downplay a win, hold back an idea in the meeting, or let someone else take the credit to keep the peace. While doing this can make your day feel smoother and less stressful, it can also teach you that being good at your work is something to minimize and apologize for. When your success creates friction you didn’t cause, shrinking yourself rarely fixes the problem. It mostly just makes you smaller.

Minimizing your success to keep the peace doesn’t fix your work environment.

When the Reward for Good Work Is More Work

There’s a term for what happens when the most capable people on a team keep getting handed more to do: performance punishment. You finish a project ahead of schedule, so the next one immediately comes your way. A colleague leaves, and their work lands on your desk along with a “you’re just so good at this,” with no change in title or pay. In academia it tends to look like being asked to join an extra committee, taking on the advisee nobody else knows what to do with, or the program review that somehow becomes yours. Each request on its own seems reasonable enough. Taken together, they add up to a much bigger job, with many more hours, than the one you were hired to do.

In a healthy workplace, this kind of imbalance usually gets noticed and corrected. In a toxic workplace, it can settle in as the way things work, because the people giving the most are also the least likely to push back. You’ve proven you can absorb it, so they keep asking you to do more. Left alone long enough, this is often where work stress starts turning into burnout.

You’ve shown that you can handle more. The question to ask yourself is whether what you’re getting back from your work comes anywhere close to what you’re giving.

When Your Job Becomes Who You Are

For many of us, work became part of our identity a long time ago. It’s where we feel most capable, where our effort has been most reliably rewarded, and usually the first thing we mention when someone asks us how life is going. Don’t get me wrong; caring deeply about your work is a good thing. The challenge starts when your job and your sense of self get so tangled together that a lukewarm review, being left off an important email, or a dismissive comment from a department chair or manager becomes a judgment on who you are as a person.

This is where criticism in a toxic workplace does some of its most lasting damage. It tends to be vague, inconsistent, or out of proportion to what actually happened. Some people are able to shrug it off. High achievers, who are usually already their own toughest critic, tend to internalize it. It becomes part of who they are and begins to feel like evidence that can feed their imposter syndrome. Knowing whether you’re dealing with an imposter experience or whether you’re having a completely normal reaction to an abnormal situation can make it easier to respond to the right problem.

Either way, it’s worth remembering that you were a whole person before you started this job. Your values, your character, and your abilities existed before you were hired. The toxicity you’re dealing with now hasn’t taken them away. You’ll still be that same person should you choose to leave.

Your values, your character, and your abilities existed before you were hired, and they’ll still be there should you choose to leave.

Golden Handcuffs and the Comfort of the Familiar

If you are considering leaving your role, there’s the question of what it would actually cost to do so. Costs of leaving a role are sometimes referred to as golden handcuffs (benefits that make a job hard to walk away from, even when the job itself has become hard to stay in). In a corporate role, they might be the bonus that pays out next spring, the stock that vests in two years, or a salary that would be hard to match anywhere else. In academia they often look different but hold just as tightly: years spent working toward tenure, a research program built around one institution, a field with only a handful of openings each year, or a family settled in the town the job brought you to. For many parents of younger children, one of the strongest ties is flexibility, like being able to take a child to a doctor’s appointment in the middle of the day or make it to a school performance at two in the afternoon. That kind of freedom is hard to find in other jobs, and it can make a difficult workplace feel worth tolerating. These are real considerations, and staying because of them is often a reasonable choice.

High achievers also face a less obvious pull. You know how to succeed in your current role. You understand the unwritten rules, you know which battles are worth picking, and you’ve built a reputation that took years to earn. Starting somewhere new means going back to being the person who doesn’t know any of these things, and for someone whose sense of security comes from being good at things, this can feel riskier than staying somewhere that’s slowly wearing you down. The familiar can feel safer than the unknown, even when the familiar is the thing that’s hurting you.

Nothing here is meant to talk you out of staying. Choosing to stay is a legitimate decision, as long as you’re the one making it. The handcuffs can make it feel like you can’t leave. Making the decision yourself means staying, for now, for reasons that matter to you.

Choosing to stay is a legitimate decision, as long as you’re staying for reasons that matter to you.

Where to Start When You Recognize Yourself Here

If parts of this felt uncomfortably familiar, you don’t need a plan by Friday. A few smaller shifts can help you see your situation more clearly before you decide anything.

Start by noticing which of these situations sound like yours. Maybe it’s the workload that keeps growing, or how much of yourself and your identity is wrapped up in your role. Naming what’s happening makes it easier to see it as something your workplace is doing, rather than something you need to fix by trying harder.

Reconnect with what you care about outside of performance. High achievers can go a long time measuring their worth by output alone. It helps to get clear on your values, like the type of person you want to be at work and how you want to show up for the people around you. From there, you can notice where your current job supports those values and where it gets in the way. This tends to tell you more than any pros-and-cons list.

Talk it through with someone outside your workplace. Toxic environments have a way of narrowing your view until the version of events you hear at work starts to feel like the only one. Someone outside that system, whether a trusted friend, a mentor, or a therapist, can help you see your situation more clearly.

If parts of this felt uncomfortably familiar, you don’t need a plan by Friday.

Your Strengths Deserve a Better Environment

Staying steady under pressure, always delivering, and being the one everyone turns to are why you’ve come as far as you have in your career. In the right environment, these strengths will keep serving you well. In a toxic one, they need more protection than you’ve probably been giving them, and noticing how much the workplace has been leaning on them is where that protection starts.

This is the second piece in my series on toxic workplaces. Next, I’ll walk through how to decide whether to stay or gowhen your job feels unsustainable, and how to make that call based on what you value, rather than on exhaustion or fear.

If you’re in Indiana, Ohio, or Minnesota, virtual sessions mean you can get support without adding one more thing to an already full calendar. And if you’re in or near Bloomington, I can see you in person at my office on the square.

You don’t have to untangle what’s yours and what’s the workplace’s on your own.

No pressure, just a conversation.


Next
Next

6 Signs You’re in a Toxic Work Environment (and You’re Not Just Having a Bad Day, a Week, a Month…or Even a Year!)